Matter Labs CEO Alex Gluchowski described Polygon Zero’s allegation that zkSync copied their code with out correct attribution as “unfounded, deceptive, and very disappointing,” in keeping with an Aug. 4 publish on X, previously Twitter.
Polygon’s plagiarism accusation
On Aug. 3, Polygon Zero mentioned Matter Labs copied “performance-critical parts” of its Plonky2 zero-knowledge system code with out correct attribution.
The Polygon group acknowledged that the zkSync group made deceptive claims about its newest proving system Boojum being 10x sooner than Plonky2. It argued that this was unimaginable, contemplating Boojum copied the efficiency code of Plonky2.
Polygon Zero additional strongly criticized these actions, saying they have been antithetical to the core ideas of the open-source motion. In keeping with the group, such practices might pose a major menace to smaller growth groups, as “better-funded rivals” would possibly exploit their efforts with out giving due credit score.
Matter Labs denial
In response, Gluchowski mentioned claims that zkSync reused code with out attribution couldn’t be farther from the reality.
In keeping with Gluchoswki, Plonky2 and Boojum are implementations of the RedShift building, which the Matter Labs group launched three years earlier than Polygon Zero launched the Plonky2 paper.
Though Polygon referred to RedShift within the paper, Gluchowski mentioned the group didn’t give any credit score to Matter Labs.
He defined that solely about 5% of Boojum code relies on Plonky2 code, and the group acknowledged Plonky2 within the README file and the introduction publish.
Nevertheless, he admitted that zkSync might have dealt with this higher and used a extra customary method for attribution, which might be finished subsequently. However he criticized the general public allegations as in opposition to the spirit of Open Supply.
“If the Polygon Zero group wished extra credit score, the best manner would have been to submit a pull request which we’d have fortunately accepted.”
In the meantime, Gluchowski expressed shock about complaints concerning benchmarking. He famous that there was no want for the Polygon Zero group to place out its code for benchmarking and endorse it in the event that they have been sad in regards to the benchmarking perform or un-optimizing their implementations.
The publish Matter Labs CEO dismisses Polygon Zero claims of zkSync plagiarism appeared first on CryptoSlate.